Jump to content

Fingers and Thumbs

tonyw3

By tonyw3
in The Lounge

 Share

Recommended Posts

tonyw3

tonyw3

Posted
Posted
Lately I've been thinking really deeply, mulling over a question in my mind. For the sake of this debate we will categorise the thumb as a finger (no doubt there are some that will take issue with this point). But the question is, why is it that we have 5 fingers and the Simpsons have four and this appears to be perfectly adequate?
Link to comment
https://www.eastdulwichforum.co.uk/topic/9692-fingers-and-thumbs/
Share on other sites
HAL9000

HAL9000

Posted
Posted

I read somewhere that the Simpsons were designed with only three fingers and a thumb as a cost-saving measure because it is cheaper and quicker for the animators to draw the cartoons that way. Apparently, that decision has saved the producers a fortune over the years.


As for why we have four-plus-one - we inherited them from an ancient ancestor species that probably acquired them through a random but ultimately useful mutation.


Or, perhaps, it's God's way of encouraging us to adopt a base-10 maths system for some reason we have yet to fathom?

tonyw3

tonyw3

Posted
  • Author
Posted

HAL9000 Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> I read somewhere that the Simpsons were designed

> with only three fingers and a thumb as a

> cost-saving measure because it is cheaper and

> quicker for the animators to draw the cartoons

> that way. Apparently, that decision has saved the

> producers a fortune over the years.


HAL9000 I can't believe for one moment that the producers would have sacrificed a finger from each hand of the Simpsons merely to save a few cents. I know that businesses are always looking for cost-saving measures, but to chop a finger off each hand from each of the characters would, to my mind, be too painful to even contemplate.;-)


> Or, perhaps, it's God's way of encouraging us to

> adopt a base-10 maths system for some reason we

> have yet to fathom?


As for the base-10 theory, this could have some Android logic behind it as you would no doubt appreciate.

HAL9000

HAL9000

Posted
Posted

tonyw3 Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> HAL9000 Wrote:

> --------------------------------------------------

> I can't believe for one moment that the

> producers would have sacrificed a finger from each

> hand of the Simpsons merely to save a few cents.


Well, the standard for cartoon 'fingers' was set by Walt Disney and here is what he had to say about it:


"Leaving the finger off was a great asset artistically and financially. Artistically five digits are too many for a mouse. His hands would look like a bunch of bananas. Financially, not having an extra finger in each of the 45,000 drawings that make up a six-and-one half minute short has saved the studio millions."



> > Or, perhaps, it's God's way of encouraging us

> > to adopt a base-10 maths system for some reason we

> > have yet to fathom?

>

> As for the base-10 theory, this could have some

> Android logic behind it as you would no doubt

> appreciate.


Actually, I mentioned God because, as I'm sure you've noticed, He is the only Simpsons character drawn with four fingers and a thumb (except in one episode which was explained as an ?animation error? ? although many religious fans continue to believe it was the work of the Devil).

Ladymuck

Ladymuck

Posted
Posted

HAL9000 Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------


> Actually, I mentioned God because, as I'm sure

> you've noticed...



mmmm...is that your tongue in your cheek HAL9000?



>...He is the only Simpsons character

> drawn with four fingers and a thumb


I have to say, I would never have known that...your observational powers are exceptional...


>(except in one

> episode which was explained as an ?animation

> error? ? although many religious fans continue to

> believe it was the work of the Devil).


ha ha ha...


Very amusing post HAL9000!

  • 2 weeks later...
Ladymuck

Ladymuck

Posted
Posted

HAL9000 Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------


>...I mentioned God because, as I'm sure

> you've noticed, He is the only Simpsons character

> drawn with four fingers and a thumb....



Just had to dig this up. Was at a friend's last night with her two children who happened to be watching The Simpsons on DVD. It was an episode featuring God...and I absolutely collapsed with laughter when I saw that He did in fact have four fingers and a thumb (unlike the other characters) - just as you said HAL9000. The two children thought I was completely bonkers of course as they couldn't understand the cause of my hysterics.


But really, fancy noticing that HAL9000.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing
  • Advertise Here

  • Latest Discussions

    • bob
      Franklins is being sold

      By bob · Posted

      DR Yes he had not been very well for about the last 2 or 3 years but was making some progress, we use to see him down LL getting his shopping and stop and catch up on all matters Ed. I Pm'd just before Christmas and received no reply which was not like him so I did have concerns about his health but I had no other means of contacting him. R.i.P Foxy Bob S 
    • Insuflo
      Councillor McAsh defects to the Greens

      By Insuflo · Posted

      So, private polling for Labour in London puts Labour and the Lib Dems with the same number of seats on Southwark Council come May. It’s not clear from this Guardian article (link below) if that will be all due to Labour losses or if the Lib Dems will actually make some gains in Southwark. Either way, the Greens are set for a massive surge in seats across London, if the polling is correct. Labour urged to listen to progressive voters or face ‘political earthquake’ in London | Labour | The Guardian
    • malumbu
      Be careful on the pavements...

      By malumbu · Posted

      I shouted at someone who pushed by me on the tube last week, as they got off I said your could least say "excuse me". Somebody told me "they did".  Whoops, humble pie. I have no idea whether the original poster overreacted. I have done far too many times, and try (or should try harder) to learn from this, and do regret not handling things better/calmer.  I expect most of have similar 'guilty' secrets. There's a separate thread on why, being British, we apologise when it is not our fault, or when we simply want to get past someone.  Excuse me (and/or thank you when they move out of your way) is appropriate.  Even people who you wouldn't fancy meeting on a dark alley do this.  And I apologise for being so judgmental, I couldn't find the right words.   (if you remember this ad you may be considered by some to be old)  
    • SE Londoner
      Electrician recommendation: Electrical Initiative Ltd

      By SE Londoner · Posted

      Leon came to do a full electrical check and sort out some problem lights yesterday. He came on time, was very polite and friendly and was a pleasure to do business with. He didn’t laugh at me when one of the problems was very badly designed lights (even if they look great) where the bulbs needed to be changed. He’ll probably get years of repeat business from these lights. His rates are very reasonable and I don’t hesitate to recommend him. p.s I found him on this forum but have only just joined, specifically to leave Leon a review.

East Dulwich Forum

Established in 2006, we are an online community discussion forum for people who live, work in and visit SE22.

Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...