Jump to content

Recommended Posts

  • 2 weeks later...

Finally got round to The Road as I've given up on ever going to the cinema again.

It's all a bit grey isn't it.


Beautifully and poetically written though. A Wasteland for a new generation. Which thinking about it isn't a bad comparison. Whereas TS Eliot's masterpiece came in the wake of the great war and the death of optimism, McCarthy's comes on the back of climate change and that ever seductive idea to writers that the future is worse than past. Not sure what causes the apocapalypse though. Some suggestion of a nuclear war, is it ever really clarified?

Scratch that.


having finished it it really is just an overlong and rather starkly beautiful way of saying i's you pint half full or half empty'. And some stuff about questioning the validity of imbuing meaning into existence.


Is life a gray (sic) road full of ennui and horror with the occasional peach juice or crafted sextant moment? Is there a greater meaning; should there be an embracing optism; brings us back to TS Eliot who I think leaned toward the negative when asking the same questions.


I sense McCarthy will be buying the subsequent round and it's truly a redemtive book, whether for him or no I couldn't say. Lovely though, lovely, it'll be getting a second read tomorrow.

I read The Road a few months ago and as a father with a son of similar age as the boy in the book it certainly pulled quite a few heart strings for me. A dark book no doubt but at the end of it I felt strangely happy and uplifted as the father had achieved his goal of making his son safe.


I felt he was trying to show what humans are capable of if pushed to the extreme, totally compelling reading which i could not put down until finished.

Spoiler Vince!!!


The son is the innocent 'good' the father is just a world-weary, stoical, refusing to give up bugger, ultimately driven by good but he needs his son to remind him of this was my take. I think it's ultimately uplifting for both of their qualities. Not sure if I could read it again straight away though Mockney!

Some people find it harrowing but I too find it ultimately uplifting


For me the biggest emotional impact came from the book challenging the reader on seemingly every page to question how they choose good over bad - and how, rather than wait until the kind of environment we read about in the book, we should be making those choices more conciously in our current situation


But yeah, like quids, I didn't rush to read it the day after!


the film makes as good a film as can be possibly made from the material btw - but it can't match the book

*SPOILERS !!!!!!!*


The book is ultimately a world view crafted and narrated in third person by 'the man' (the clue is he slips into first person in his flashbacks). Dark as that post apocalyptic world certainly is, it isn't necessarily as bad as the man makes out. The boy often challenges that view and is ultimately vindicated through most of the encounters.


I also thought there was a HUGE nod to Philip K Dick's 'Man in the High Castle'. There is much reference to dream realities and the telling of stories. There is an acknowledgement that the characters are slightly aware that they aren't real, that they are products of the author's own fears and inner struggle with life's meaning and the moral decisions we have to make everyday.

It works on so many myriad levels of cautionary tale, passion play and metaphor.

Marvellous stuff and most deserving of it's pullitzer.

oops sorry about the lack of spoiler warning.


Im not sure if i would like to re read The Road though.


One author I have re read many times is Kinky Friedman, but every time I mention him to anybody no ones heard of him, any one here heard of him? Very off beat funny crime writer based in New York and Texas.

  • 1 month later...
Nothing to Envy by Barbara Demick, the LA Times bureau chief in Beijing, and former Seoul correspondent is a good read. She befriended several N Korea refugees in S Korea and tells their story. I recommend it, mostly because it is well written and has good narratives and also because it gives a human face to a place that has become a byword for faceless conformity.

Lord Sornoff Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo - Stieg Larsson.

>

> An absolute corker that I can't seem to put down.

> Tragically the author, Stig Larsson, died before

> seeing his 'Millenium Trilogy' becoming a

> worldwide best seller.

>

> I thoroughly recommend it.


I just got on to the second one...totally gripped! Recommendation seconded.

  • 10 months later...

well, call me a masochist.


I've moved on to Blood Meridian.


Cripes, and I thought The Road was a harrowing read. But whereas I found that a rather redemptive book, I can see no goodness in this novel. It's pretty Swiftian in is savage indictment of humanity.


Mind you it's a more beautiful read, and the Judge must stand out as one of the great literary characters, some of his sermons actually stopped me in my tracks (and sadly I can't help but agree with many of his conclusions).


I finished last night and had to read the last couple of pages several times over, so amazing was it.


I should read something about puppies and flowers now, but like a fool I started Child of God today.


Like i say, masochist.

No sympathy - I did scoff at the time.


Having finally paid my library fine last weekend, I've gone a bit mad.


In the last 10 days I've read:


"Toast" - bit of a bitch our Nigel

"The Winter Ghosts" - absolute drivel

"Cider with Rosie" - charming and perceptive

all three Larssons - hype justifiable;

"Trust Me I'm a Junior Doctor" - funny and poignant

"An Empty Death" - makes Kate Mosse look erudite

"Don't tell Alfred" - delightful puff, makes one hanker after hats and gloves

the last two "Joshua Files" - pretty good (teen stuff so don't bother unless you are weird like me)

"The Woodcutter" - bloody brilliant

and am currently enjoying "The Complaints" - juicy non-Rebus cop stuff.

"all three Larssons - hype justifiable"


Really? I thought the first one was an excellent thriller, but it started getting in equal measures silly and boring in the latter two, and Salander just that little bit to cartoonish superhero for my taste.


And I can't help feeling Larsson was a bit of a perv.

Know what you mean about the perv thing.


What I mean is that I'm very easily put off by recommendations. Anything that's Booker Prize or, God forbid, Richard & Judy approved is the kiss of death for me. Larsson was so lauded that I avoided him for ages and was pleasantly surprised.


Can't tell you how disappointing "The King's Speech" was when I saw it - for the same reasons.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Discussions

    • I think it's connected with the totem pole renovation celebrations They have passed now, but the notice has been there since then (at least that's when I first saw it - I passed it on the 484 and also took a photo!)
    • Labour was damned, no matter what it did, when it came to the budget. It loves go on about the black hole, but if Labour had had its way, we'd have been in lockdown for longer and the black hole would be even bigger.  Am I only the one who thinks it's time the NHS became revenue-generating? Not private, but charging small fees for GP appts, x-rays etc? People who don't turn up for GP and out-patient appointments should definitely be charged a cancellation fee. When I lived in Norway I got incredible medical treatment, including follow up appointments, drugs, x-rays, all for £200. I was more than happy to pay it and could afford to. For fairness, make it somehow means-tested.  I am sure there's a model in there somewhere that would be fair to everyone. It's time we stopped fetishising something that no longer works for patient or doctor.  As for major growth, it's a thing of the past, no matter where in the world you live, unless it's China. Or unless you want a Truss-style, totally de-regulated economy and love capitalism with a large C. 
    • If you read my post I expect a compromise with the raising of the cap on agricultural property so that far less 'ordinary' farmers do not get caught  Clarkson is simply a high profile land owner who is not in the business as a conventional farmer.  Here's a nice article that seems to explain things well  https://www.sustainweb.org/blogs/nov24-farming-budget-inheritance-tax-apr/ It's too early to speculate on 2029.  I expect that most of us who were pleased that Labour got in were not expecting anything radical. Whilst floating the idea of hitting those looking to minimise inheritance tax, including gifting, like fuel duty they also chickened put. I'm surprised that anyone could start touting for the Tories after 14 years of financial mismanagement and general incompetence. Surly not.  A very low bar for Labour but they must be well aware that there doesn't need to be much of a swing form Reform to overturn Labour's artificially large majority.  But even with a generally rabid right wing press, now was the opportunity to be much braver.
    • And I worry this Labour government with all of it's own goals and the tax increases is playing into Farage's hands. With Trump winning in the US, his BFF Farage is likely to benefit from strained relations between the US administration and the UK one. As Alastair Campbell said on a recent episode of The Rest is Politics who would not have wanted to be a fly on the wall of the first call between Angela Rayner and JD Vance....those two really are oil and water. Scary, scary times right now and there seems to be a lack of leadership and political nous within the government at a time when we really need it - there aren't many in the cabinet who you think will play well on the global stage.
Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...