Jump to content

Recommended Posts

JohnL Wrote:

-------------------------------------------.

>

> Still 23 Lions in the squad not 11 Welshmen 7

> Englishmen 4 Irishmen 1 Scotsman in my view.



Well JL, that's what Willie John McBride would have said of course but places have to be on merit not just on the basis that, ok I am your country coach so ill pick you for the Lions.

it's Gatland - with his reputation on the line he's gone back

to playing what he knows best - we call it Gatlandball in Wales

the Aussies call it Warrenball over there and some people say Cementball

(Gatland is known as Cementhead in some circles)



The Lions committee must have known what they were getting.


In Wales alone people like Hook, Peel, Tipuric never fitted into his plan.

and it has worked to an extent.


This final test could be a brutal 'bloodbath' if played his way as

the plan will be to bash them into submission. Rowntree and Farrell

seemed to influence his thoughts on this in Rounds 1 and 2.


A large amount of English player will come off the bench to 'close it'.




Alan Medic Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> What makes it worse is he has Tugawhathisname on

> the bench as the only outside back replacement. He

> was dreadful in his last match and looked lacking

> in confidence. Why pick Phillips at scrum half?

> He's been poor.

British Lions: Willie John McBride accuses Warren Gatland of damaging 'concept and ethos of Lions'

4 Jul 2013 08:41


Irish legend 'amazed' by decision to drop Brian ODriscoll and critical of Gatland's tour tactics and team selection policies


Legend Willie John McBride has accused Warren Gatland of damaging the ethos of the Lions with his tactics on tour and team selection for Sydney.


The greatest Lion in history fears Gatland?s approach will lead to another defeat in the third Test.


McBride, captain of the 1974 Invincibles tour of South Africa, rapped: ?The first thing that came into my mind was that Robbie Deans must be laughing.


?The Australian media and others have convinced the Lions to drop Brian O?Driscoll. I find it amazing. His work-rate has been superb and his influence on tour terrific.


?The problem is our forwards are not giving our backs ball they can use. If we were still playing the second Test today, we still wouldn?t have scored a try.


Gatland has picked a big strong team of players for Saturday to run at the opposition. It?s not about skill, it?s not about the concept the Lions have always had where we moved the ball and scored tries.


?In contrast, Australia saw what we were doing in Melbourne, moved the ball and scored a try to win.?


McBride continued: ?I?ve heard a lot about the Welsh players.


?But when you are with the Lions, you pick Lions. That means you pick the best players around you.


?The concept and ethos of the Lions is beginning to slip and that worries me a lot.


?They chose a bloke (Tom Court) who happened to be at home in Brisbane, he didn?t earn his place. They brought Shane Williams, who was a very good player, over because he was in Japan. I don?t think this is the concept of the Lions I know.?

Australia coach Robbie Deans, meanwhile has expressed his surprise at the news, saying: ?We?d anticipated that Brian would be there, but we haven?t spent the time and consideration that the Lions staff will on the matter.


?It would have been a great sign off for Brian because he?s a legend of the game.


?I have no doubt that he understands the nature of the industry. He?s been around long enough to know that and understand that.


?He?s been part of many Lions series so it would have been a fitting send off for him, but he?ll also have perspective because he?s a quality bloke.


?He?ll be disappointed and from our perspective it?s a little bit of experience gone.


?Those are decisions that aren?t made lightly and Warren will have given it due consideration and believes what he has put together will serve him better.


?We have a lot of respect for Brian. He?s stung us in the past in 2009, scoring in the last minute for Ireland to draw. He?s a class player and class bloke.?

London - Legendary Lions coach Ian McGeechan added to the pressure on current boss Warren Gatland by saying Friday he would have picked Brian O'Driscoll for this weekend's crunch Test against Australia.


New Zealander Gatland, who as Ireland coach gave O'Driscoll his international debut, has been engulfed in controversy ever since omitting the 34-year-old star centre O'Driscoll from what many would thought would be his Lions swansong.


Saturday's match in Sydney is also the decider in a three-match campaign the Lions must win if they are to record their first series victory in 16 years.


Former Scotland centre McGeechan, in charge of victorious Lions tours in Australia (1989) and South Africa (1997), said he would have stuck with the midfield duo of Jamie Roberts and O'Driscoll he deployed four years ago, rather than partner Roberts with Welsh colleague Jonathan Davies as Gatland has done.


"I would have paired Brian O'Driscoll with Jamie Roberts for the third Test in Sydney. For me, they are the best centre partnership in world rugby," McGeechan wrote in Friday's UK Daily Telegraph.


"They showed that in the two Tests they played in South Africa four years ago, before both were injured," added McGeechan, coach of the Lions side that lost to the Springboks in 2009 when Gatland was one of his assistants.


However, McGeechan, who represented the Lions on their unbeaten tour of South Africa in 1974, said while "that would have been my call against Australia it has not been Warren Gatland's".


"And I would not criticise it. Selection, particularly on a Lions tour, is a very personal thing...And Warren obviously feels this is the best way forward."


Gatland, seconded to the Lions from his 'day job' as Wales coach has also been slammed for selecting 10 Welshmen in his starting XV for Saturday's must-win game.


Critics have pointed out how Wales have lost their last eight Tests against Australia but a diplomatic McGeechan said of Gatland: "He most certainly will not see it as a Welsh way. He will see it as a Lions way. These players are Lions now."


McGeechan said the presence of "complete centre" O'Driscoll, not even on the bench for Saturday's match, would have been especially valuable after tour captain Sam Warburton, another Wales star, was ruled out through injury.


"He is also a great leader. I worry that the Lions will miss that sort of influence," McGeechan added of O'Driscoll, appointed captain for the 2005 tour of New Zealand only to be injured barely minutes into the first Test against the All Blacks following a controversial 'spear' tackle.


"There are players out there that have not been in the pressure situations that Brian has faced countless times down the years.


"When it is bedlam all round, he has the ability to remain calm and see just what is needed tactically for the next five or 10 minutes.


"Not everyone has that gift."

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Discussions

    • Does anyone know when the next SNT meeting is? I am fed up with my son being mugged on East Dulwich Grove! 
    • The issue must be everywhere at the moment. I was visiting a friend last week in Bermondsey, think we were walking  down Linton Rd & we dodged 7 dog poos. It was disgusting. 
    • Thanks for your message — I actually took the time to look into what CityHive does before posting my original comment, and I’d encourage anyone with questions to do the same. Yes, the Companies House filings are overdue — but from what I’ve gathered, this seems likely to be an accountant or admin issue, not some sign of ill intent. A lot of small, community-based organisations face challenges keeping up with formalities, especially when they’re focused on immediate needs like food distribution. Let’s not forget CityHive is a not-for-profit, volunteer-powered CIC — not a corporate machine. As for the directors, people stepping down or being replaced is often about capacity or commitment — which is completely normal in the voluntary and community sector. New directors are sometimes appointed when others can no longer give the time. It doesn’t automatically mean bad governance — it just means people’s circumstances change. CityHive’s actual work speaks volumes. They buy most of the food they distribute — fresh produce, essential groceries, and shelf-stable items — and then deliver it to food banks, soup kitchens, and community projects across London. The food doesn’t stay with CityHive — it goes out to local food hubs, and from there, directly to people who need it most. And while yes, there may be a few paid staff handling logistics or admin, there’s a huge volunteer effort behind the scenes that often goes unseen. Regular people giving their time to drive vans, sort donations, load pallets, pack food parcels — that’s what keeps things running. And when people don’t volunteer? Those same tasks still need to be done — which means they have to be paid for. Otherwise, the whole thing grinds to a halt. As the need grows, organisations like CityHive will inevitably need more support — both in people and funding. But the bigger issue here isn’t one small CIC trying to make ends meet. The real issue is the society we live in — and a government that isn’t playing its part in eradicating poverty. If it were, organisations like CityHive, The Felix Project, City Harvest, FareShare, and the Trussell Trust wouldn’t need to exist, let alone be thriving. They thrive because the need is growing. That’s not a reflection on them — it’s a reflection on a broken system that allows people to go hungry in one of the richest cities in the world. If you're in doubt about what they’re doing, go check their Instagram: @cityhivemedia. You’ll see the real organisations and people receiving food, sharing thanks, and showing how far the impact reaches. Even Southwark Foodbank has received food from CityHive — that alone should speak volumes. So again — how does any of this harm you personally? Why spend time trying to discredit a group trying to support those who are falling through the cracks? We need more people lifting others up — not adding weight to those already carrying the load.
    • Well, this is very disappointing. Malabar Feast  has changed its menu again. The delicious fish curry with sea bass no longer exists. There is now a fish dish with raw mango, which doesn't appeal. I had dal and spinach instead, which was bland (which I suppose I could/should have predicted). One of my visitors had a "vegetable Biriani" which contained hardly any vegetables. Along with it came two extremely tiny pieces of poppadom in a large paper bag.   This was embarrassing, as I had been singing Malabar's praises and recommending we ordered from there. The other mains and the parathas were OK, but I doubt we will be ordering from there again. My granddaughters wisely opted for Yard Sale pizzas, which were fine. Has anybody else had a similar recent poor (or indeed good!)  experience at Malabar Feast?
Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...