Jump to content

Recommended Posts

A disunited SNP, more like? We in teh south don't really get what is going on up there from anything other than a London broadsheet or tabloid, or even the BBC and ITN - it is broadbrush when it comes to the regions/nations (probably because time is short on a bulletin and being general appeals to most people, so not knocking them). The nationalists/separatists/SNP/Scottish National Party (different people call them different things) are very popular but there is a large proportion of people who are fed up of them, especially the leadership. I hold no side but just ask that people educate themselves more on the positives and negatives of any nationalist party, even if it goes against what you believe. Next week should bring more attention to the workings of the SNP, if not its policies.

Nigello Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------


> Next week should bring more attention to the workings

> of the SNP, if not its policies.


Spoke to a Scottish friend last night, they think the SNP is more than capable of shooting itself in the foot e.g the Salmond issue, but for many voting SNP is simply a conduit to achieve independence, they don't feel any allegiance to then run with the SNP if it's achieved, again strong similarities with England and Brexit i.e non-Tory voters in England voting for the Tories to 'get Brexit done'...

Salmond's allegations have been redacted after concerns by the Scottish Crown Office and some (mainly the Spectator) are calling conspiracy hinting that Sturgeon was involved in some sort of dirty tricks operation.


Sturgeon denies having any involvement and accuses the accusers of being conspiracy theorists.



It's all murky up there in Scotland and that's not just the weather.

If Sturgeon is forced to resign in the near future, will it take the wind out of the sails of the independence movement, at least for the near term?


Clearly the SNP and independence issue is not goin got go away, but Sturgeon is clearly a formidable political and the face of the independence movement...

I'd guess Ian Blackford the Westminister head of the SNP would take over ? Would be no change in policy - may even be a harder line.


She's giving evidence now - I can't see her resigning. No-one in the UK government resigns anymore whatever the accusations, why should she ?

It's a sad state of affairs where lying/misleading is common practice, it wasn't so long ago that we expected integrity from our lords and masters. But now (Trump/Johnson) it no longer seems to matter to many of the electorate. Not that others didn't tell fibs, massage the truth etc but endemic now.

Very true about the general public's lack of interest in lies from our leader.....but looking more broadly than just politics, is it because society at large has too many versions of what 'truth' is? So it all starts to become a bit meaningless?


The reason I raise this...I was skimming an article today about the upcoming Meghan Markle/Harry interview with Oprah....and in one of the clips pre-released of the inteview, Oprah asks Meghan ?How do you feel about the palace hearing you speak your truth today??...YOUR truth?...WTF does that mean? It used to be something was either true or false....sure, we can talk about peoples 'perceptions' or 'interpretation' of events....but YOUR truth?

diable rouge Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> It's not only the Scots who are revolting...

> https://www.itv.com/news/2021-03-04/is-the-united-

> kingdom-on-the-brink-of-a-break-up



Wales will follow Scotland to an extent - but there is a bit of a campaign at the moment (yes cymru)


https://www.yes.cymru/

  • 2 weeks later...

BBC News - Alex Salmond inquiry says Nicola Sturgeon misled committee

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-scotland-politics-56451170


Should she stay or should she go now?

If she go's, there will be trouble

And if she stays it will be double

So come on Nicola and let me know

No sign of her resigning yet.


I can't help thinking of the affair in Wales (Carl Sargeant killing himself and Carwyn Jones resigning "at the end of the year"). That never really had the same level of media coverage in England.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carl_Sargeant

Ahhh Sky News update. The leaked (and it is only leaked) report says she misled parliament, the guidelines say you should resign if you KNOWINGLY mislead parliament.


The fix is in :)


Although of course nobody resigns over misleading anybody about anything these days - it's just how politics works..

Its notable how the decline in objective truth and need for integrity is perpetuated by tribes of ALL political colours. It seems in both mainstream and social media that tribalism generally trumps the need to avoid outrageous hypocrisy for many people these days....


For those who are typically pro-brexit/pro-tory (the two are of course not one and the same, but im generalising), they are accepting/silent on Boris's lies/inaccurate statements/misleading; but insistent that Nicola must go.


For those who are typically anti-brexit/anti-tory (so a generalization of many posters on the EDF perhaps?!), there's a general 'whataboutery'; glossing over the Nicola lies/inaccurate statements/misleading; and pointing the finger at Boris, saying well of he doesn't go, then why should she..?


The outcome is a general degrading of a requirement for the truth, and unfort pointing the finger at the 'other side' misses the point and perpetuates the decline...we are all complicit in this race to the bottom unfortunately....

I haven?t read the leaked report but if it is as described then yes she should resign. Of course I recognise I don?t have a dog in the fight and so it?s easy for me to say that. For me it?s a genuine conundrum, I think the pro-Brexit/pro-Tory side have been successful by dispensing with many democratic norms so I can see the temptation for my side of the argument to do the same. On the other hand you can?t get a healthy, liberal society through populism and norm breaking, so better to try to hold the line and hope that it starts resonating with the public.


Fundamentally the last 5-10 years in the UK and US have shown that the general public don?t place much value on honesty in politics and until that changes the behaviour of politicians won?t change either.

Cat,


I don't think the lies that Boris Johnson has told and those that Nicoloa Sturgeon has been accused of are on anything like the same scale.


Boris's lies have been fundamental whoppers. He has been dismissed from two journalism jobs for lying, and once as a shadow mininister. He has told inmumerable bare-faced lies whilst campaigning and in office, the most famous being the ?350M for the NHS. It is clear that he is deceitful in his personal life too - and indeed this has crossed over into his political life as when he was sacked by Michael Howard.


The accusations against Nicola Sturgeon seem to be of a more technical nature. Did she know about the allegations (now legally disproven) against Alec Salmond on Mar 29th or April 2nd - was a phone call between the two recorded as government or party business, etc.


FYI - I would fall into the Labour/Remain camp - but on that basis, have no particular candle for SNP politicians - I would also like the UK to remain intact, but at this stage - who can blame them for wanting to go their own way?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Discussions

    • Tommy has been servicing our boiler for a number of years now and has also carried out repairs for us.  His service is brilliant; he’s reliable, really knowledgeable and a lovely guy.  Very highly recommended!
    • I have been using Andy for many years for decorating and general handyman duties. He always does a great job, is very friendly and his prices are competitive. Highly recommend.
    • Money has to be raised in order to slow the almost terminal decline of public services bought on through years of neglect under the last government. There is no way to raise taxes that does not have some negative impacts / trade offs. But if we want public services and infrastructure that work then raise taxes we must.  Personally I'm glad that she is has gone some way to narrowing the inheritance loop hole which was being used by rich individuals (who are not farmers) to avoid tax. She's slightly rebalanced the burden away from the young, putting it more on wealthier pensioners (who let's face it, have been disproportionately protected for many, many years). And the NICs increase, whilst undoubtedly inflationary, won't be directly passed on (some will, some will likely be absorbed by companies); it's better than raising it on employees, which would have done more to depress growth. Overall, I think she's sailed a prudent course through very choppy waters. The electorate needs to get serious... you can't have European style services and US levels of tax. Borrowing for tax cuts, Truss style, it is is not. Of course the elephant in the room (growing ever larger now Trump is in office and threatening tariffs) is our relationship with the EU. If we want better growth, we need a closer relationship with our nearest and largest trading block. We will at some point have to review tax on transport more radically (as we see greater up take of electric vehicles). The most economically rational system would be one of dynamic road pricing. But politically, very difficult to do
    • Labour was right not to increase fuel duty - it's not just motorists it affects, but goods transport. Fuel goes up, inflation goes up. Inflation will go up now anyway, and growth will stagnate, because businesses will pass the employee NIC hikes onto customers.  I think farms should be exempt from the 20% IHT. I don't know any rich famers, only ones who work their fingers to the bone. But it's in their blood and taking that, often multi-generation, legacy out of the family is heart-breaking. Many work to such low yields, and yet they'll often still bring a lamb to the vet, even if the fees are more than the lamb's life (or death) is worth. Food security should be made a top priority in this country. And, even tho the tax is only for farms over £1m, that's probably not much when you add it all up. I think every incentive should be given to young people who want to take up the mantle. 
Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...