Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Forecasting the weather is difficult as it is dependent on numerous natural and man-made phenomena. It is the reason that supercomputers were invented. The better the model and the higher quality the data, the more reliable (in terms of probability) forecasts become.


The Met Office has one of the best services in the world. It is right that this executive government agency is run more commercially but I never understood why the national broadcaster had to go to a tendering exercise. The result is poorer quality forecasts from the Meteo group.


So either switch to ITV or go the Met Office direct: https://www.metoffice.gov.uk/


I'm expecting that this is one of the most boring threads on the EDF and to get no posts.

I used to flat with a weather forecaster in another country - he set up a business (run out of our ground floor) in competition with the Met Office equivalent, based on their data feed and supplementing it with info from a network of people on the ground (farmers, amateur meteorologists etc) who used to phone our flat with info late at night and into the early hours. He always told me that although the met office model had much more data than previously, it still wasn't over a long enough period, and there was much to be said for people who knew their environment. He won the contract for the equivalent of radio 4 and was wildly successful (the met office continued to supply tv).


So whether or not the change to someone else has worked in this case, maybe weather is another area where there is not just a simple, one version of "the science"? I've used dark sky until recently, it seems to have got less accurate since being adopted by apple.

I blame Brexit,Trump,fireworks being set off an antisocial times, local road closures which create traffic chaos and men skipping on the pavement....


But back to the topic at hand....at the risk of generalizing...the British do get off on talking about the weather and weather forecasting. Smugly as its said, growing up in Australia, we never really worried too much about the weather forecast, as invariably it was 'fine'....but the resident Brit in my house (Mrs Cat) usually checks the weather 3 times before breakfast....

Agreed Cat on the first sentence. Actually I am having a good chuckle.


But as the second paragraph this is one of the things that binds us together in the UK - little else at the moment.


Sue, forecasting is a probability not an accurate prediction. Nigello, do compare the two. Beeb was useless today - forecast of occasional rain. Met Office gave 10% or less likelihood. I'm doing some work outside. Met Office won yesterday too. Often they are similar but generally Met Office better.


Wow, I'm now optimistic that this thread will overtake the one on bus travel before the freedom pass is valid.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Discussions

    • Do you have any binoculars?  My first ever sighting of swifts was when I was lying in the park, trying out some 10x25s.  Nothing at all  within plain sight, but when I was playing around with the focus -- presumably for clouds or planes -- suddenly there they were.   I've still never heard any in real life though.  The sample I heard on the BBC website sounded fairly high frequency and not very loud, so I suppose I might miss some; but then there have been precious few reports I've seen here of any being heard.  The only one I remember is Jenny1's last year. 
    • None of that makes any sense. Rumour and vibes-based governance...   Meanwhile, thanks in part to the NIMBY tendencies of certain councillors, 23 London council areas saw 0 (zero) new housing units under construction in Q1 2024. Pitiful. About 724,000 (net) people moved to the UK in 2024, a sizeable chunk of them to London. The already high demand for housing is increasing, and the supply isn't changing at all. Rent prices (and therefore taxpayer funds paid to private landlords through Housing Benefit) are going up...and new housing units are objected to because they're "visible" and because a fear that rich foreign students will live there. 
    • Lots of hoverflies (that look like drone honeybees) about today. Also, tiny (< .5cm) bees/wasps 
    • Posting for friend. Both missing since Thursday eve. Last seen in back garden on Soames Street, their garden backs onto gardens in bellenden road, avondale rise and copleston road. Gladys went missing a month or so ago and I know she was chased by a large black and white cat and again he is back in my garden and now both my cats missing. They are both chipped and neutered. No collars.  Thank you. 
Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...