Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Helmets don't offer as much protection as people think. They won't protect you from any kind of strong impact nor any kind of substantial weight bearing. I also have found that when wearing a helmet some drivers take less care around me.


It seems clear from the OP that the driver was entirely at fault. Glad the lady is ok.

ObsessedwithOlives Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> As much as I have concern for the lady's safety,

> I'd like to add she wasn't wearing a helmet which

> I think is ridiculous nowadays. Noone seems to

> wear them!! Is a concern for fashion more

> important than one's safety??



while i personally wear a helmet i don't think a helmet would have prevented this accident taking place somehow. If the driver is at fault, the lady's safety precautions are irrelevant. The lady is unhurt (but bloody shaken up imagine) so what would a helmet have changed about this accident?

ObsessedwithOlives Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> As much as I have concern for the lady's safety,

> I'd like to add she wasn't wearing a helmet which

> I think is ridiculous nowadays. Noone seems to

> wear them!! Is a concern for fashion more

> important than one's safety??


Much research which shows that you're more likely to be in an accident wearing one than without. http://www.bath.ac.uk/news/articles/archive/overtaking110906.html


And it would have made no difference in this case it seems.

Although in this case it wouldn't have made a difference - a colleague of mine is currently recovering at home after being badly injured while cycling home from work. She broke 3 ribs, her collar-bone and her arm was broken in two places.


Luckily she was wearing a helmet, but even just a knock from impact without wearing one is a risk.

silverfox Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> Lady on bike just got knocked off by a car cutting

> corner at junction between Lordship Lane and East

> Dulwich Grove...

>

> How can you cut a corner at this junction? Do you

> mean by the pedestrian crossings by the

> roundabout?



No I mean as I said it.. a car turning right from Lordship Lane onto East Dulwich Grove cut the corner (basically turning infront of traffic turning left) and hit a lady on her bike.

a helmet probably saved a friend of mine's life (according to the paramedics) in a car acciden,t as he went head first into the road- still required some corrective surgery on his face.


getting knocked off and hitting your head on a kerb could be quite nasty too

The OP is clearly saying the car turning right cut the corner. The cyclist would have had to be in front of the oncoming traffic (waiting to turn left) to be hit. Whereever the Cyclist was, the driver turning should not have been on that side of the road as he/ she turned.


*crossed posts*

Indeed - and the argument made by LCC is that compulsion for adults will have a greater health effect than not compelling helmet wearing as those not cycling due to compulsion (ref Australian research here) will be less healthy given the health (mental and physical) benefits of cycling


titch juicy Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

.....

>

> getting knocked off and hitting your head on a

> kerb could be quite nasty too

ObsessedwithOlives Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> She was infront of the cars and the car turning

> didn't see her.



You mean he didn't look for her. Motorcyclists get this all the time too when drivers hit them...'I didn't see you'. Funny how they always see Police on motorcycles though.

The only protection a helmet will give is from impact of light force. A cycle helmet is only polystyrene with a thin plastic shell. They split and crush fairly easily.


I always wore a helmet every time I cycled for years. I don't always now (usually shorter daytime journeys) and I definitely think drivers are more careful around me when I'm not wearing a helmet. But it's also easier to see I'm female too without a helmet...so maybe that plays a role ;)

We don't know that DJKQ. The facts here seem a bit sparse and the assumption is it's the driver's fault. if I'm correct there's a box junction at that point. Who was in the box first? Did the cyclist take reasonable care/see the driver indicating? Was she ready to brake? I suppose we'll never know.


Hope he lady's okay though and I suppose we should hope the driver's not too shaken up also.

the-e-dealer Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> Get a decent Helmet then. If you don't value what

> you have inside your head then don't be surprised

> if it gets damaged.

> MY School friend's Dad - a Physicist wore a crash

> helmet in his car!



LOL :) I agree! Well not about a helmet in a car, maybe that's a step too far !

DJKillaQueen Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> ObsessedwithOlives Wrote:

> --------------------------------------------------

> -----

> > She was infront of the cars and the car turning

> > didn't see her.

>

>

> You mean he didn't look for her. Motorcyclists get

> this all the time too when drivers hit them...'I

> didn't see you'. Funny how they always see Police

> on motorcycles though.



I knocked a copper off his motorbike the other day! Never saw the bugger til he bounced off me windscreen!

the-e-dealer Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> Get a decent Helmet then. If you don't value what

> you have inside your head then don't be surprised

> if it gets damaged.

> MY School friend's Dad - a Physicist wore a crash

> helmet in his car!



By that logic, all pedestrians should be wearing helmets too! If the stats are right, it would save more lives than comelling cyclists to wear them.

Having been knocked off my bike in the summer (by another cyclist and on a cycle path), I would urge every cyclist to wear a helmet. I was knocked out and spent several hours at King's being stitched, X rayed and CTed ( not in that order). Had it not been for the helmet, things would have been a lot worse. As it was I drove my nearest and dearest mad asking the same questions over and over again for at least 3 hours, after that I began to remember what I had said but I still don't remember what happened in the accident, or how I managed to ring my relatives to let them know what had happened. Fortunately a witness rang for an ambulance and waited until my daughter arrived.

Definitely wear a helmet!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Discussions

    • Having  current and relevant experience of both Charter North and Charter East with regards to their conduct towards SEN pupils and their families, I would say that their conduct and behaviour is wholly lacking in understanding as well as making no effort to make reasonable adjustments for the SEN pupil as legally required under Equality Act 2010. Furthermore, I believe that their behaviour is wholly illegal. According to data from Ambitious About Autism, unfortunately that is not uncommon We have separately requested legal advice as to whether or not the specific conduct of the school and certain teachers constitutes a criminal offence under the Children and Young Persons Act 1933 or other legislation. These links have some very good materials to assist parents: https://www.ambitiousaboutautism.org.uk https://www.ambitiousaboutautism.org.uk/understanding-autism/education/exclusions-know-your-rights https://www.ipsea.org.uk https://sossen.org.uk   Also, this link specifically for girls with autism as this tends to be diagnosed at a much later stage than boys and requires different support and reasonable adjustments that the neither of the policies nor behaviours of Charter East or Charter North reflect. https://autisticgirlsnetwork.org   Helen Hayes MP for Dulwich & West Norwood and whose constituency includes Charter North is Chair of the Education Committee at the Houses of Parliament They published this report on the SEND crisis on 18 Sept 2025 https://committees.parliament.uk/work/8684/solving-the-send-crisis/   Ellie Reeves (Rachel Reeves’ sister and formerly Chair of the Labour Party) is the MP for Lewisham West and East Dulwich - the constituency under which Charter East falls I would urge any parents who are concerned about their children, whether SEN or not, who attend Charter North or Charter East to write to your MP canvassing their support and requesting that they write to their respective school on this subject, referencing this report of the Education Committee and the failures of Charter East and Charter North with regards to SEN, their illegal behaviour and soliciting a plan of action from them to immediately stop such behaviour and support SEN pupils with reasonable adjustments as required under the Equality Act 2010. Even if your child is not SEN, the school implementing the correct and legally required procedures materially improves the school environment for all pupils, teachers and non-teaching staff. Often the reasonable adjustments can actually be relatively minor but have a very material benefit. In our experience, there have been one or two teachers who have shown this with very positive results; however, this is the opposite of the institutional approach of both schools which is wholly negative, unsupportive and often illegal. In addition to EHCPs, there is also huge pressure at CAMHS and insufficient resource to support all cases and meet demand.  Even if families and their child are lucky to get access to it, there remains very long wait lists to access treatment.  The same is true in the private sector. A proactive and practical, common sense approach to SEN in this manner by Charter North and Charter East would also help to reduce pressure on CAMHS The latest tragedy last week at Charter North means that this is more pressing than ever.    
    • Thought I'd add a comment as sadly there are now too many primary schools for the number of children in this area... St Anthony's is a wonderful school and my 2 sons were extremely happy throughout the time they were there. They have some open days for reception and  nursery in Nov I believe and welcome children and families of all faiths and backgrounds. It has lovely staff and I cannot recommend it more highly!
    • Anyone has lavender buds they don’t want/that I could harvest/cut and use? Ideally in Peckham/ED goose green area.  Thanks in advance!
    • The tissues would absorb secretions from your nose.
Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...