Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Hello


Doctors are due to strike this Thursday over pensions, meaning that thousands of operations, hospital appointments and scans will be cancelled - is there anyone on the forum being affected by the strike who would be willing to chat about it for a small fee? Pls PM for more info. Thanks v much.

Doctors' pensions are simply deferred pay - doctors have paid for their pensions themselves, their scheme is not unstainable, it is not in deficit and now they are being told it's being cut.


The fact that it's the first doctors' industrial dispute for 40 years speaks volumes for the strength of feeling.


Good luck to all of them.

Huguenot Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> If doctors can defer sufficient pay from the

> public purse to generate a 100k a year pension,

> then we'd have to ask whether they're currently

> being overpaid?


They're no more overpaid than marketing people like Hugo. At least Doctors do something useful like saving lives.

Chippy Minton Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> Doctors' pensions are simply deferred pay -

> doctors have paid for their pensions themselves,

> their scheme is not unstainable, it is not in

> deficit and now they are being told it's being

> cut.

>

> The fact that it's the first doctors' industrial

> dispute for 40 years speaks volumes for the

> strength of feeling.

>

> Good luck to all of them.


If doctors are paying for the pensions themselves, how can the government cut it? Are you saying there is no taxpayer involvement here?

Dominic Lawson observed this of the new deal:


"The average doctor's pension if he retires at 68 will be ?68,000 a year. To put that in context: if you wanted to buy a joint annuity which would provide that sum in retirement (and for your spouse after your death), it would cost about ?2m on the open market [...] and of which over 85 per cent would come courtesy of the taxpayer."


i.e. to get a Doctor's pension you'd need to save two million quid before you retired.


UDT may think I don't derseve my salary, but I'll never save 2m in my lifetime, and I'm not sure that being an expert gardener or secret premiership player manager deserves much of a salary either ;-).


And 85% of that money comes from the taxpayer.


The 'private fund' that the Unions refer to is the NHS fund (which is as observed currently in surplus, but won't be in surplus once we've all lived longer in greater numbers).


The goverment is legislating for a 65 years old retirement date, and a 14.5% salary witholding to pay for the pension.


All that cash (the NHS fund or the doctor's salaries) comes from the taxpayer, and the government is quite within it's rights to negotiate the terms of those agreements.


Needless to say the doctors want to retire younger, pay less and get bigger pensions.

It's nothing to do with a personal attack on me or Marks and Spencer advertising.


The average UK adult will spend twice as much on beer every year as he does on funding the NHS.


If the taxpayer wants to pay doctors more and let them retire earlier on pensions of 68,000 a year that's entirely up to them, they are fully entitled to vote in political parties on the back of 'increase our taxes NOW' arguments.


But they don't do they?


So you'll need a more intelligent argument?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Discussions

    • Hi if anyone has one pm me cheers 
    • You can always check when they registered on the forum, if you are suspicious. But I recommended Aria, and it certainly wasn't my only post on here, and it was a genuine recommendation. ETA: And he didn't ask me to make it, to the best of my recollection. But even if he had, many local tradespeople ask people to post on here if they are happy with the work that has been done.
    • I am not a patient at this practice, but surely it is more sensible to have an initial  phone discussion, as often the GP wouldn't need to see someone face to face unless they actually needed to physically examine them? This then leaves the available face to face appointments for patients who need them. And if during  the phone call the GP felt you needed examining, then arrangements could be made for a face to face. If you feel your ailment is such that you will definitely need to be physically examined, can you not explain that to the receptionist?
    • Give Labour a chance, they've only been in government for a short time, and they inherited a mess! As regards the notice boards, to the best of my recollection they were originally intended as community notice boards, and certainly not for advertising local businesses (who would decide which businesses  should have the limited space on the boards, anyway?) East Dulwich may have become more gentrified since the boards were first introduced, but that surely doesn't mean they should now be completely  taken over for the benefit of  the "middle classes", to the exclusion of everybody else? As  NewWave says, surely these people have other ways to find out about groups and events of interest to them, which the "non middle classes" may not have access to, and even if they did may not be able to afford them. Several people including myself have complained to councillors about the state of the noticeboards in the past.  I think one of the issues is that they were originally maintained by local volunteers, who may have either moved out of the area or lost interest - or given up in despair when the boards were flypostered and/or vandalised. I completely  agree that the boards should be used for information about not for profit organisations in the area, but if regular maintenance can't be provided and/or they continue to be vandalised, then I think it would be better if they were removed altogether.
Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...