Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Hi all. Not sure the best place to post this so I thought I'd start here!


Is there such thing as an exchange of skills system yet in ED? Got thinking about this since moving into my new flat here 3 weeks ago. There's a fair bit I want to do to the place so am spending hours looking through the EDF for recommendations for plumbers, gardeners, decorators etc (and very handy it is too!)


However I'm a professional classical musician and there are undoubtably people looking at the forum for music/theory/instrumental lessons. I often have free tickets for big concerts in London too, but they are usually wasted!


How brilliant to swap these skills to everyone's advantage! (tu)

Any thoughts?


Helen :)

Link to comment
https://www.eastdulwichforum.co.uk/topic/22732-exchange-of-skills/
Share on other sites

HelBel65 Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> Hi all. Not sure the best place to post this so I

> thought I'd start here!

>

> Is there such thing as an exchange of skills

> system yet in ED? Got thinking about this since

> moving into my new flat here 3 weeks ago. There's

> a fair bit I want to do to the place so am

> spending hours looking through the EDF for

> recommendations for plumbers, gardeners,

> decorators etc (and very handy it is too!)

>

> However I'm a professional classical musician and

> there are undoubtably people looking at the forum

> for music/theory/instrumental lessons. I often

> have free tickets for big concerts in London too,

> but they are usually wasted!

>

> How brilliant to swap these skills to everyone's

> advantage! (tu)

> Any thoughts?

>

> Helen :)


I'm good in the sack . . .

It's a great idea but.... have you considered the tax implications?


On a small scale where it's just about a couple of people helping each other out it's probably not worth HMRC pursuing, but on a 'village' scale they may not be so lenient.


Technically barter (swapping) amounts to evasion of income tax, corporation tax or VAT and could possibly also amount to fraud.


Make it visible on a local forum and the evidence is right in front of them!


Secondly there's practicality: it may be difficult to identify two indviduals who have corresponding items. It may require three, four or more individuals operating in a network to ensure that everyone gets what they want.


Comparative value then becomes difficult to ascertain, so it usually involves the creation of a 'value' score for each product that then becomes a currency in its own right.


You'd need some sort of monetary authority to oversee that to ensure transparency and accountability.


Where this was achieved in Totnes, the Totnes pound was freely changeable with sterling at a 1:1 value - and since neither customers nor businesses were obliged to accept it, it became a timely and effective marketing gimmick that promoted local business, rather than one that leveraged it.


I'd probably just stick to occasional friendly swaps to avoid the pitfalls and possible legal issues that an 'organised' arrangement would entail.

My mum has been instrumental in setting up one of these in a small town in Middle England's herartlands as part of the whole transition towns thingy.


I must say, as noble and sweet and well intentioned as it all sounds, my reaction was a little bit like Huguenot's. The moment it stops being good folk acting all neighbourly to each other and becomes a medium of exchange I can't see how it avoids becoming a different version of money.


Surely anyone who's skills are in greater demand gets more of other people's services in return for their own, in other words they get paid more.


And to echo Huguenot, if it becomes popoular and formalised then the state inevitably wants to get their fair share, at which point everything becomes quantifiable and divisible and you either have to work for the state or use some sort of transferrable means of exchange to reflect the value of your services offered, perhaps by creating IOUs out of paper and writing different numbers on them to reflect how much of a service they can be exchanged for or for anything of equivalent value.


You can see where I'm going with this can't you.... ;)

  • 2 weeks later...

This is a concept I've been interested in for a while. It seems that there's quite a few folks doing it, this site seems to have a fairly decent set up: http://www.swapaskill.com/


I'd love to know the law on this? Surely it can only be perceived as fraudulent when it's approached as a time banking thing, where units of 'time' are earned and can be spent within the participating community. That's basically currency. But to me that is different than a plumber fixing an electricians sink in exchange for new sockets??

This is a bit of side ways view , but relevant as it shows the power of communal action & labour


I've long admired this


Also, if you google Organop?nicos ( for some reason I can't get the link to work) you might find it interesting too



Personally I say trade on


( and the trade have done this with each other for years btw )


I mean really, what are they (the man) going to do? take you to court because you plumbed a sink in in exchange for a few light sockets.


:-S


Netts(tu)

I think it's a good idea, but it's likely to work best for tasks which aren't your profession. Good examples might be teaching languages, helping out with DIY, driving, gardening, (non-professional) music lessons, music production, etc. The moment you're giving up your time as a professional, it's likely to get rather too serious.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Discussions

    • Does anyone know when the next SNT meeting is? I am fed up with my son being mugged on East Dulwich Grove! 
    • The issue must be everywhere at the moment. I was visiting a friend last week in Bermondsey, think we were walking  down Linton Rd & we dodged 7 dog poos. It was disgusting. 
    • Thanks for your message — I actually took the time to look into what CityHive does before posting my original comment, and I’d encourage anyone with questions to do the same. Yes, the Companies House filings are overdue — but from what I’ve gathered, this seems likely to be an accountant or admin issue, not some sign of ill intent. A lot of small, community-based organisations face challenges keeping up with formalities, especially when they’re focused on immediate needs like food distribution. Let’s not forget CityHive is a not-for-profit, volunteer-powered CIC — not a corporate machine. As for the directors, people stepping down or being replaced is often about capacity or commitment — which is completely normal in the voluntary and community sector. New directors are sometimes appointed when others can no longer give the time. It doesn’t automatically mean bad governance — it just means people’s circumstances change. CityHive’s actual work speaks volumes. They buy most of the food they distribute — fresh produce, essential groceries, and shelf-stable items — and then deliver it to food banks, soup kitchens, and community projects across London. The food doesn’t stay with CityHive — it goes out to local food hubs, and from there, directly to people who need it most. And while yes, there may be a few paid staff handling logistics or admin, there’s a huge volunteer effort behind the scenes that often goes unseen. Regular people giving their time to drive vans, sort donations, load pallets, pack food parcels — that’s what keeps things running. And when people don’t volunteer? Those same tasks still need to be done — which means they have to be paid for. Otherwise, the whole thing grinds to a halt. As the need grows, organisations like CityHive will inevitably need more support — both in people and funding. But the bigger issue here isn’t one small CIC trying to make ends meet. The real issue is the society we live in — and a government that isn’t playing its part in eradicating poverty. If it were, organisations like CityHive, The Felix Project, City Harvest, FareShare, and the Trussell Trust wouldn’t need to exist, let alone be thriving. They thrive because the need is growing. That’s not a reflection on them — it’s a reflection on a broken system that allows people to go hungry in one of the richest cities in the world. If you're in doubt about what they’re doing, go check their Instagram: @cityhivemedia. You’ll see the real organisations and people receiving food, sharing thanks, and showing how far the impact reaches. Even Southwark Foodbank has received food from CityHive — that alone should speak volumes. So again — how does any of this harm you personally? Why spend time trying to discredit a group trying to support those who are falling through the cracks? We need more people lifting others up — not adding weight to those already carrying the load.
    • Well, this is very disappointing. Malabar Feast  has changed its menu again. The delicious fish curry with sea bass no longer exists. There is now a fish dish with raw mango, which doesn't appeal. I had dal and spinach instead, which was bland (which I suppose I could/should have predicted). One of my visitors had a "vegetable Biriani" which contained hardly any vegetables. Along with it came two extremely tiny pieces of poppadom in a large paper bag.   This was embarrassing, as I had been singing Malabar's praises and recommending we ordered from there. The other mains and the parathas were OK, but I doubt we will be ordering from there again. My granddaughters wisely opted for Yard Sale pizzas, which were fine. Has anybody else had a similar recent poor (or indeed good!)  experience at Malabar Feast?
Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...