Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Sorry...


( not really )


But in my dyslexic minds eye I keep reading "Pendants on the EDF"


http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/4/41/Amber.pendants.800pix.050203.jpg


Which in it self is quite nice


( I like the one on the left or is that the right...erm..? )



W**F

There are times when being pedantic is the correct thing to do, especially if someone, a body, is trying to convince you using suspect facts.


However, the thing that annoys me is the rogue apostrophe that is becoming commonplace, partly I suspect due to thick, badly educated, advertising creatives/executives, eg, CD's, DVD's, 1800's, 1900's etc.


In all these cases the words are plurals (NB more than one, thick advertising jerk) - the apostrophe (ie possessive here)shouldn't be there.


To say, eg, 'In the 1960's the Beatles were great' means 'In the of 1960s the Beatles were great' - ie nonsense. Look at most Virgin Airlines/HMV records ads and you'll see the English language being murdered.


Ps, s's after people's names. Licence/license, as noun, interchangable if used consistently, ie you can use American English as long as you are consistent. In English the rule is c when noun, s when verb, ie, (English, English) it is the role of magistrates to license public houses to sell alcohol. Pubs are licensed to sell alcohol. Pubs have licences to sell alcohol.


Other than that, yes, pedants, don't you hate them.

Keef Wrote:

-------------------------------------------------------

> Although they can both be correct, I can't stand

> s's. There is a big department store in Liverpool

> called Lewis's, always made me seethe.



But that's how you say it Keef - Lewises. Or do you say you're going to Lewis (ooh, like Morse)? Punctuation is your friend Keef - it's there to help you say it proper.


Edited due to hangover spelling

Ha ha!


You are, in all likelihood, not going to believe this Mr. H, but I thought you might say as much! Indeed, it is for that reason I decided to use the wotsits ("). Do they not make a difference?


Anyway, while you grace us with your presence, you wouldn't happen to know whether the second "h" of "Ha ha" above should be a capital letter? My pea-brain says no, but my eyes tell me it looks peculiar in lower case. Louisiana? Santerme? Any other forum pedants? (*gives big fat cheeky grin*).

I understand after a little research that St. Thomas themselves claim the use of the apostrophe is attributable to there being two Saints of that name.


This appears to be both post rationalisation, and it compounds the error by trying to insist that it is correct.


The correct usage if it referred to multiple individuals would be either 'Saints Thomas' or a more colloquial 'Saint Thomases' either of which could carry the apostrophe and possibly an additional 's' according to taste.


I say post rationalisation, because wall plaques in the older part of the hospital name it as "St.Thomas's".


Hence the current usage seems to be a modern invention, and apparently quite arbitrary, and likely to be based on conversational convenience rather than grammatical accuracy.


George Bernard Shaw campaigned long and hard that for the removal of apostrophes from posessives. He referred to them as 'uncouth bacilli'. I'm considering supporting him.


It also lead to this rather clever assertion from one anonymouse commentator:


"If in doubt it is better to leave an apostrophe out than to put it in. This is because if you leave it out incorrectly this will be put down either to an oversight or to an affinity with the views of George Bernard Shaw. On the other hand, if you put it in incorrectly this will be attributed (rightly) to ignorance."

With Barons Court the mistake isn't the one you think it is.


It should actually be Baronscourt as it was named after an Irish estate with connections to Sir William Palliser who built the district.


Hence no apostrophe, but it should be one word....


Interesting eh?

Well I used to sell advertising on the LU, so stories of those kind were my in-trade!


It reminds me of a tube fancy dress party where one chap came as Cockfosters - with an artfully placed can of poor quality Australian lager - and another who came in with a piece of turf that he stuck behind the telly - Hyde Park Corner.


Now, back to me dictionary... I've reached 'specious'. Hmmm.

Huguenot, I stand corrected, humbled and thoroughly ashamed of my foolish suggestion that St Thomas' referred to two saints.


I am clearly out of my depth, so I'm going to go back to giggling at katie1997's and SimonM's posts (or should that be katie1997 and SimonMs'? Or katie1997 and SimonM's?) about cheeses.

It most certainly wasn't a foolish suggestion, I have done you a disservice!


It was a thrilling conundrum, involving deception and misdirection in the highest of places. We are no more than pawns in their Great Game.


It's a challenge that lies at the very core of Bitishness and even attracted the attention of GBS.


It was, in short, a superb contribution for pedants!

I wonder - could the plurality assigned to St. Thomas be a (gnostic) echo of the New Testament words Dydimous Thomas?


The name "Thomas" comes from the Aramaic word for twin: T'oma, but the Greek word Dydimous also means twin.


The phrase "Dydimous Thomas" at John 20:24, therefore, translates into English as "twin, twin".

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Discussions

    • Does anyone know if the above is taking place this year. Can't seem to find it mentioned anywhere?   Simon
    • Hello, with the weather improving, I thought I would flag up the free access to leisure centres in southwark. 1. If you are experiencing poor mental and physical health and live in the borough, the GP exercise referral service allows up to three months of free use of leisure centers. There are three levels of support, and you can even refer yourself. read more for more info: Kickstart, Active Boost and Cardiactive - Everyone Health Southwark   2. If you don't have challenges with physical ands mental health, you can access the free swim and gym for a year. for more info: Free swim & gym eligibility requirements – Leisure Facilities in Southwark 3. Are you a blue badge holder? you can apply for the AD Permit, a virtual payment which allows disabled drivers to part on single and double yellow lines without the need of displaying a blue bae in the windscreen. there is also information for disabled residents to use the Low Traffic Neighborhood (LTNs) around the borough.  Exemptions for Blue Badge holders | Southwark Council Want more information? use the councils website: www.southwark.gov.uk               
    • I am about to tomorrow. I only just realised after asking some neighbours today. Agreed that smaller households should of course pay less, like discounted council tax bills for those on benefits for example. However as our bills have gone up astronomically generally in the last few years, I do feel hardworking families are being penalised... also avid gardeners will be penalised in the summer when gardens are watered no doubt. 
    • Hello Womanofdulwich, I had a meter installed in the summer of last year. Currently my bills have fallen massively. Can you remember which month your water meter was installed? Also I received two appointments, one from a group of staff in orange who decide if the property is suitable for the water meter, and then a second appointment for the meter to be installed, did you have the same thing? Are you saying as well that you was cold called regarding the water meter, or are you saying someone from Thames water turned up, at your door unannoyed?   Lastly (so sorry to through so much questions at you) how many bedrooms do you have and how many people live at the property?    
Home
Events
Sign In

Sign In



Or sign in with one of these services

Search
×
    Search In
×
×
  • Create New...