Well the debate in my head goes on... Le Chardon, been loads and mostly for lunch so wouldn't be anything special for a birthday lunch! Franklins, love it, but never been for lunch and it IS a Tuesday so probably will be rather quiet (but then on a Tuesday where wouldn't...). Palmerston, well my man works in a fab gastropub in Chelsea and I don't think he would be charmed if I took him to "work" in a weird kinda way. Especially if it is not as good, no insult to Palmerston as I do think it's a great pub! I love Barcelona, but as you say DavidC, not the most romantic of places! Mmmm, now Beauberry House, mixed reviews here and I am rather interested. However, frigid is not a word that makes me think romantic and sexy... Number 22 in Herne Hill, don't know it so may have to do a little research Locale is my local, if it wasn't it would be the one that I would choose... Chez Bruce tops my list but I really wanted something walking distance... Was going to give Biagio La Lanterna a try but they are closed for reburb! If I have to travel that distance there are so many choices, Le Poulet Pot for french, Bibendum for seafood, La Famiglia for Italian, and that's just a handful around Chelesa. There is Farringdon/ Spitalfields, West End, etc. all just a short bus ride. Maybe I am being too fussy but what the hell, now if Moxons had a restaurant attached I would go just so that I could pig out on seafood... Thanks all for your help!!! Will let you know how this story ends ;-) p.s. Still open to suggestion...