We had the same situation last year - and deliberated over it. Decided to keep our daughter with the childminder and delay the nursery place until she was nearly 3. I felt the practically one to one attention was something we had to take into account, more variety in getting out and about with the childminder (Nursery would have been one room plus outside space)and even with the years delay means daughter will be at nursery for 2 years. I also discussed it with the childminder and told her my instinct was we should stay with her - they did masses of arts and crafts, learning colours, numbers, animals etc - but questioned her as to whether she felt our daughter was 'growing out' of their routine. Nursery would have been cheaper (!) but I am pleased we made the decision we did! Katie